Putting a procedure online removes neither a supporting document nor a processing rule from it: users now face them without a staff member in front of them. Public service digitalisation is therefore decided procedure by procedure, and the choice of the first one shapes what follows.
The first procedure to digitalise combines a high volume, simple processing, an audience already familiar with online services and a failure with no effect on a right or an income. It only opens once the online service has been made accessible to people with disabilities. Another access channel (counter, telephone, post) remains available as long as part of the audience cannot complete it alone. Complex procedures come next, with support and an alternative solution.
The criteria for public service digitalisation, procedure by procedure
Each candidate procedure is read on five lines, with the information the department already has.
| Criterion | Sign in favour of opening first | Sign that invites waiting | Where to find the information |
|---|---|---|---|
| Volume | Many applications per year | Few applications, all different | Statistics from the processing department |
| Complexity | Few documents, stable rules, a decision that follows from the file | Situations to be assessed, exchanges with the user during processing | Share of incomplete files, reasons for rejection |
| Consequences of failure | A delay with no effect on a right | A right, an income or a permit that depends on the application being registered | Texts applicable to the procedure |
| Audiences | Users who already use other online services, or professionals | A known share of users without equipment, without a connection or who struggle with written material | Reception staff, associations, share of files completed by a third party |
| Accessibility | A service audited across the whole journey | A component that fails the audit | Audit conducted according to the RGAA |
Volume justifies the investment and quickly provides measurements. Taken alone, it misleads: a mass procedure whose audience is vulnerable makes a poor first choice.
Complexity, for its part, can be partly reduced before going online. Each supporting document removed from the file lightens the procedure on all access channels. The so-called “tell us once” principle points in this direction: it aims to ensure that users do not have to provide again information that an administration already holds. The order matters: a form built before simplification freezes the existing complexity.
The framework set by the Conseil d’État for a mandatory online channel
Offering an online channel and imposing it are two separate decisions. According to the Conseil d’État, Articles L. 112-8 to L. 112-10 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration give users a right to contact the administration electronically, without imposing it on them.
In a decision of 3 June 2022 (No. 452798), delivered in relation to residence permit applications, it ruled that the regulatory authority can make the use of an online service mandatory for a procedure with a State department. It sets a condition: to allow users normal access to the public service and to guarantee to the persons concerned the effective exercise of their rights. The regulatory authority must take into account the purpose of the service, the degree of complexity of the procedures, their consequences for those concerned, the characteristics of the digital tool and those of the audience, in particular its difficulties in accessing or using online services. For residence permits, the decision requires support for people in difficulty, then an alternative solution when the online service remains unusable for reasons relating to its design or the way it operates.
These criteria overlap with the grid. Their application to a given procedure, all the more so outside State departments, is a matter for your legal department.
In its report “Dématérialisation et inégalités d’accès aux services publics” (Digitalisation and inequalities of access to public services, January 2019), then in its follow-up report of February 2022, the Défenseur des droits recommends that a legislative provision require several means of access to public services to be preserved, so that no administrative procedure is accessible only by digital means. The 2022 report notes that no such provision had yet enshrined this right.
Digital accessibility, a condition for opening
Article 47 of Law No. 2005-102 of 11 February 2005 places an accessibility obligation on the online public communication services of public-law legal entities, among other bodies. Decree No. 2019-768 of 24 July 2019 concerns the accessibility of these services to people with disabilities, and the general accessibility improvement framework (RGAA), published by the interministerial digital directorate (DINUM), provides the method of verification.
Several points in the framework weigh on the decision. The audit covers a sample that includes all the pages making up a process, such as a multi-page form: a procedure is checked from the first step to the last. The service’s home page displays the result through a statement: “fully compliant”, “partially compliant” or “non-compliant”. Finally, when an exemption for disproportionate burden affects content or a feature linked to the core missions of a body entrusted with a public service mission, it must be accompanied by an alternative providing an equivalent service.
The consequence is practical: accessibility is checked before opening, on the complete journey. If a procedure opens when its audit has failed, the other access channel is the only one available to some users.
When to maintain another access channel
The other channel is maintained in the following situations:
- the procedure determines a right, an income or a permit, and part of the audience cannot complete it alone;
- the online service is not yet accessible, or one of its features is subject to an exemption;
- the online service may be unavailable or run into a situation it does not anticipate, which calls for a fallback procedure.
Its form is chosen according to the audience: counter, telephone, post, or support by a staff member who enters the data together with the user. A single processing circuit is preferable: the reception staff member enters data in the same online service as the user. This requires the business application behind the form to expose its functions. When it is old and closed, the subject falls under application modernisation; without this work, the online procedure risks ending in re-entry.
Staff work shifts, from data entry towards support and towards the cases the form does not anticipate. This shift is prepared with them: it is the subject of change management, applied here to reception and processing staff.
After opening, a few measurements show whether the other channel can be reduced: the share of files completed without help, the step at which users give up, the reasons for contact, the share of files submitted by a third party.
Procedures to keep for later
Some procedures benefit from waiting: those whose rules are going to change; those whose volume does not justify development; those that combine complexity, a vulnerable audience and serious consequences. The latter come after a first procedure that will have broken in the team, reception and measurements.
The online service is built in increments, opened first to a restricted group of users and staff, according to the approach described on our page dedicated to custom software development. The procurement framework and budget cycle of these projects are presented on our page dedicated to the public sector.
The decision to open, and who can reduce the other channel
The decision to open a procedure online fits on one page: the procedure chosen and how it reads against the grid, the result of the accessibility audit, the other channel maintained with the resources allocated to it, the measurements taken after opening.
One last line deserves to appear there: who can reduce the other access channel, on the basis of which measurements, and how far. In a public service, this signature falls to the authority that answers for access for all users.