Should you aim for the PMP or the PgMP when you have been leading projects for several years and a programme is on the horizon? To choose PMP or PgMP, the criterion is the object the person leads, or is about to lead; seniority comes after. Among PMI certifications (Project Management Institute), the PMP, Project Management Professional, covers leading a project: a defined result to be delivered, within a scope, a timescale and a budget. The PgMP, Program Management Professional, covers leading a programme: several linked projects, run together to obtain benefits that none of them would produce alone.
A project manager who intends to remain one therefore looks towards the PMP, and a person leading a programme towards the PgMP. That leaves the case of someone moving from one to the other, and situations where neither credential fits. Eligibility requirements, fees and renewal rules are set by PMI and published on pmi.org: they do not appear in this guide.
Credentials of the same nature, covering different objects
The two credentials are of the same nature. They certify individuals: an organisation can obtain neither. They attest knowledge and experience, assessed by reference to a body of practice, and neither prescribes a method.
Their object separates them. The PMP is intended for practising project managers, and attests that they master the practices of project leadership: scope, timescales, costs and risks, leading the team and stakeholders, whether the project is run in a predictive, agile or hybrid way.
The PgMP is aimed at programme directors. Its subject matter is what happens between projects: interdependencies, the benefits expected from the whole, governance. The programme director does not redo the project managers’ work. They answer for the effect that their deliveries produce together, as described on our page on programme management.
Our entry on PMI certifications sees them as distinct professions rather than successive grades. The two credentials also share a limit: they attest a foundation of knowledge and a track record, and leave entirely open the question of their holder’s judgement when faced with the next difficulty.
PMP or PgMP according to the role held today
The starting point is the role actually performed, which the job title does not always reflect.
A “programme director” may lead, under that name, a single large project: one scope, one plan, one team, one go-live date. Size changes nothing. As long as the task is to deliver a defined result, the object is a project, and the related credential is the PMP. Conversely, a “project manager” may coordinate several projects entrusted to others, arbitrate between them and report on benefits to a sponsor. They are then doing a programme director’s work under another name.
To place a post, we suggest looking at a few facts:
- project managers each answer for their delivery, and the person coordinates them;
- dependencies between projects are tracked, with a need date for each;
- benefits are carried by business owners, and the person reports on them to the sponsor;
- the sponsor expects arbitrations between projects from them.
When these facts are all present, the post is a programme post, and the PgMP corresponds to the role held. When none of them is, it is a project, whatever its size. In between, the mandate needs to be clarified with the sponsor, and the credential will wait.
Moving from project to programme without confusing the post and the credential
There remains the initial situation: a person who has led projects, holds the PMP or not, and is entrusted with a first programme.
The PgMP attests knowledge and experience in programme management. It therefore has little to say about a person who has not yet held this role. The exact requirements appear in the candidate handbook that PMI publishes for each credential, to be read before any plan to apply.
The order that follows is that of the profession. Taking up the post comes first, with what it requires: a written mandate with the sponsor, delegation thresholds, a programme office to maintain the registers. The design of this office falls under our page on setting up a PMO.
For a person who holds no credential and whose experience is in project leadership, the PMP is the credential that corresponds to what they have already done. It says nothing about how they will lead a programme in the future.
The view of an employer who is hiring or funding
An employer meets the question in another form: which credential to ask for in an advertisement, which one to fund, how much weight to give it.
In recruitment, the PMP provides information about experience of project leadership and about a vocabulary. In a candidate for leading a programme, it indicates that they have led projects. It covers neither dependencies, nor benefits, nor the governance of a set of projects, which are the subject matter of the PgMP. Both serve as reference points for assessing a profile, and the interview does the rest. We suggest asking the candidate about a dependency that slipped and what they did about it, or about a benefit and the name of the person who answered for it.
Funding a credential makes sense when it corresponds to a role held or assigned. Offering the PgMP to project managers who will not lead programmes amounts to certifying for the sake of certifying.
Finally, an individual credential says nothing about the maturity of the organisation. A programme may bring together a PgMP-certified director and PMP-certified project managers, and still lack common rules for reporting information. Writing them and enforcing them falls to a structure such as the PMO.
The situations in which neither the PMP nor the PgMP fits
The question disappears when the role is neither leading a project nor leading a programme. A person who is starting out, or who takes part in projects without leading them, falls under PMI’s entry-level credential, the CAPM. A portfolio manager selects and prioritises projects and programmes in the light of strategy: the related credential is the PfMP, and the discipline is described in our entry on PPM. An agile practitioner or a risk specialist will find specialised credentials in the same catalogue, the PMI-ACP and the PMI-RMP.
It also disappears when the credential is expected to be a remedy. A programme whose sponsor does not attend, whose benefits have no business owner or whose arbitrations are not made does not recover by certifying its director. What is missing then is governance, to be taken up again with the sponsor.
Finally, it can wait. A person who holds the PMP and takes on their first programme does not have to decide on the day of their appointment: the PgMP can be considered once the programme is under way, according to what they will actually have led in it.