Skip to content
Technology transformation expertise firm · ARDIANE Group Innovate, secure, succeed

Transformation management and PMO

PRINCE2 or PMP: what to take away when one is a method and the other a certification?

In brief

PRINCE2 is a project management method that an organisation adopts; the PMP is a Project Management Institute certification that attests to a person's experience and knowledge. Management Square sets out here the criteria that lead to choosing PRINCE2 or PMP, or both, depending on whether the question comes from an organisation or a project manager, and the cases where it is wrongly framed.

Page contents

The search PRINCE2 or PMP compares two things as if they belonged to the same category, whereas one is a method and the other a personal certification. PRINCE2 tells an organisation how to govern a project: with which roles, which decision points, which documents. The PMP, awarded by the Project Management Institute (PMI), attests to the experience and knowledge of a person who leads projects.

The question therefore receives a different answer depending on who asks it. An organisation looking for a common framework to govern its projects looks towards the method: the PMP will not give it one. An organisation that wants a benchmark of its project managers’ level, or a person who wants recognition of their experience, looks towards the certification. The two can be combined. Sometimes the question is also wrongly framed, when the real need is a management framework that neither a manual nor a credential puts in place.

A method on one side, a personal certification on the other

The comparison becomes blurred because each of the two names calls to mind a second one: PRINCE2 its certificates, the PMP the PMBOK Guide.

PRINCE2 is first and foremost a method, presented in our entry on PRINCE2: a project board that decides, a project manager who leads within set limits, a project divided into stages authorised one by one. It comes with individual certifications, Foundation and Practitioner. On a CV, “PRINCE2” refers to one of these certificates: the first attests to knowledge of the method, the second to the ability to apply it.

The PMP is a certification, described in our entry on PMI certifications. It prescribes no method. The PMBOK Guide, with which its exam is associated without being limited to it, is a knowledge guide, with no imposed organisational model.

The same search thus contains two comparisons. For an organisation, the issue is whether it adopts a method, and what place it gives to individual credentials. For a person, the issue is choosing between two credentials: one attests to mastery of a specific method, the other to experience and knowledge measured against a body of practice.

PRINCE2 or PMP for an organisation looking for a framework

An organisation cannot obtain the PMP: PMI credentials certify individuals. For an organisation, the decision concerns the adoption of a method, then the place of credentials in recruitment and career paths.

Choosing PRINCE2 as a framework makes sense when the weakness of projects lies in their governance: decisions taken who knows where, a sponsor absent between launch and acceptance testing, a justification that nobody rereads. The method provides a model to tailor. Some checks come before the decision:

  • are sponsors willing to sit on a board that decides at the end of each stage? The method commits senior managers as much as project managers;
  • is the organisation ready to tailor the method to the size of its projects, as one of its principles requires?
  • do its customers, partners or contracting authorities already use this vocabulary?

Giving weight to the PMP meets a different need: having a benchmark of a project manager’s level, during recruitment or an internal move, and a vocabulary shared between teams. The certification changes nothing in the way the organisation decides. Certified project managers can work side by side with no common framework.

The two choices add up, for the reason given in our entry on PRINCE2: the method sets governance and leaves open the project management techniques that the PMI body of knowledge documents. At programme level, other frameworks take over: our page on programme management places them.

Which credential for which project manager

For a person, or for the employer funding their career path, the choice is guided by the working environment and the experience acquired.

In an organisation that applies PRINCE2, or that works for contracting authorities that require it, a PRINCE2 certificate is immediately useful: Foundation for those who take part in projects, Practitioner for those who lead or oversee them. Outside that environment, it attests to knowledge of a method that its holder may not have the opportunity to apply.

The PMP is aimed at people who already lead projects. It attests to that experience along with knowledge, in predictive, agile and hybrid contexts. It suits an experienced project manager whose employer follows no particular method, or whose career path runs through several organisations.

Nothing requires a choice: the same person can hold both credentials. An employer has an interest in linking each credential it funds to the position held by the person, or to the one they are due to take up.

These credentials call for the same reservations. None says how its holder will judge a situation they have not yet encountered. Their eligibility requirements, exam format, fees and renewal rules change, and are checked with PMI, on pmi.org, or with the body that owns PRINCE2. Exam preparation is the business of training organisations. It is distinct from the training in common practices that a project office provides to the project managers of its own organisation.

When the PRINCE2 or PMP question is wrongly framed

The question is wrongly framed when it serves to avoid another one.

A management team that observes delays may consider certifying its project managers. If projects drift because arbitrations are not made or priorities change from one month to the next, individual credentials will change nothing. The fault lies in the organisation.

The adoption of PRINCE2 can rest on a similar calculation: relying on the method’s documents to bring discipline to projects. Without sponsors determined to play their role, the organisation gets the documents without the decisions. Applied wholesale to small projects, the method can moreover become a burden that its tailoring principle advises against.

The hesitation can also be about something else, the choice between a predictive and an agile approach. Neither PRINCE2 nor the PMP settles this point. The first deals with governance and leaves teams their delivery approach; the second covers both families of approaches.

That leaves the situation where a call for tenders or a contract imposes one of the two. The customer has settled the question, and what remains is to check exactly what it requires: a method applied to the project, or credentials held by the people involved.

In the first two situations, the need is a management framework specific to the organisation: written roles, decision points, reporting rules, and a structure that keeps them alive. This framework can borrow from PRINCE2 and rely on certified project managers. It is built on site, following the approach described in our page on setting up a PMO. A framework and a credential serve this structure, and neither takes its place.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Another question? Ask us

Should you choose PRINCE2 or PMP?

It depends on who is choosing. An organisation that wants a common framework for governing its projects looks towards PRINCE2, which is a method. A person who wants recognition of their project leadership experience, or an employer looking for a benchmark of its project managers' level, looks towards the PMP, which is an individual certification. The two can be combined.

Is PRINCE2 a certification?

PRINCE2 is first and foremost a project management method, which sets roles, stages and decision points. It comes with individual certifications at two main levels: Foundation, which attests to knowledge of the method, and Practitioner, which attests to the ability to apply and tailor it. On a CV, the mention PRINCE2 refers to one of these certificates.

Can you hold both a PRINCE2 certification and the PMP?

Yes, nothing prevents it. The two credentials do not attest to the same thing: one concerns mastery of a specific method, the other experience and knowledge measured against a body of practice. The order in which to obtain them depends on the most immediate need, for example the method in use at the employer.

PRINCE2 or PMP for an agile project?

Neither stands in the way. PRINCE2 deals with project governance and leaves teams their delivery approach, which can be agile; a variant of the method is devoted to this combination. The PMP covers predictive, agile and hybrid contexts. PMI also awards a credential devoted to agile approaches, the PMI-ACP.

Where can you check the eligibility requirements and fees for these certifications?

With the bodies that award them. For the PMP, the source is the pmi.org website, where PMI publishes a candidate handbook. For PRINCE2, the requirements are checked with the body that owns the method or with an accredited training organisation. These rules are revised by those bodies, which is why this article cites none of them.

A project to bring to completion?

A first conversation is enough to understand your challenge, identify the right people and tell you frankly what we can bring.