Skip to content
Technology transformation expertise firm · ARDIANE Group Innovate, secure, succeed

Engineering

Fixed fee or time and materials: which engagement model for which project?

In brief

Under a fixed fee, a provider commits to a defined result, for an agreed price and timescale; under time and materials, it makes skills available, billed for the time spent, and the client decides the priorities. Management Square compares the two models here on commitment, management, risk sharing and change handling, then describes the situations in which each one fits.

Page contents

In a tender file, the question fits in a tick box: will the service be bought on a fixed fee or on time and materials? A project management team puts it differently: if the need shifts along the way, who will pay for the difference?

The two formulations refer to the same choice. Under a fixed fee, the provider commits to a result described in advance, for an agreed price and timescale. Under time and materials, also called technical assistance, it provides skills billed for the time spent, and the client decides what that time is used for. Neither model wins in absolute terms. The fixed fee fits when the result can be described and verified before the start. Time and materials fits when the scope will become clearer along the way and the client has someone to set the priorities.

The provider’s promise and the share that remains with the client

Four points separate the two models, and each follows from the previous one.

The contract does not have the same purpose. Under a fixed fee, it lists deliverables and acceptance criteria; the provider must deliver what is described. Under time and materials, it lists profiles, a volume of days and a rate; the provider must assign the agreed skills and have them work with care.

The division of management follows from this. Whoever promises a result chooses the means: under a fixed fee, the provider organises its team, its methods and its schedule, while the client checks at milestones and signs off acceptance. Under time and materials, running the project falls to the client. It sets the priorities, coordinates its teams with those of the provider and answers for progress before its committee.

Financial risk follows the same dividing line. If the actual effort exceeds the estimate, the fixed fee leaves the difference with the provider, on a constant scope and unless otherwise agreed; the price proposed takes this into account. Under time and materials, every additional day is billed: the client bears the difference and, in return, pays only for the time consumed.

Finally, a change in need does not follow the same path. A request that falls outside the scope of a fixed fee goes through a change procedure: estimate, agreement, contract amendment. The gap that widens between the real project and the contracted project when amendments are delayed is covered in our article on contractual risk in project governance. Under time and materials, a change translates into a new priority in the work to be done, with no contractual act as long as the envelope ordered is sufficient.

The two models, criterion by criterion

Criterion Fixed fee Time and materials
Purpose of the contract A result: deliverables and acceptance criteria Means: profiles, volume of days, daily rate
Billing basis Overall price, paid according to a schedule of milestones Time spent, recorded in activity reports
Running the work The provider The client for priorities; the provider remains the employer of its staff
Effort overrun Borne by the provider, on a constant scope and unless otherwise agreed Borne by the client
Change of scope Estimated change request, then contract amendment New priority, within the limit of the envelope
What the client must contribute A described need, quick answers, acceptance testing Project leadership, priorities, tracking of consumption
End of the service Acceptance signed off End of the term or exhaustion of the volume ordered
Drift to watch for Savings on what acceptance does not check, scope disputes Renewal without objectives, dependence on individuals

The situations where a fixed fee fits

A fixed fee assumes a result that both parties can describe in the same way before starting. This condition is met, for example, for the technical migration of an application whose behaviour must remain identical, for a functional work package whose rules are written and stable, or for a study whose deliverable is defined.

It also fits when the client has no team to run the work day to day, and when its governance requires a firm amount before committing the spend.

Two precautions go with it. The first concerns framing. A fixed fee signed on assumptions that only use can verify turns every lesson learnt into a contract amendment; our custom software development page describes the framing that isolates these assumptions before development. The second concerns acceptance. A provider whose effort is drifting may be tempted to save on what acceptance does not look at: automated tests, documentation, code readability. Acceptance criteria limited to features let technical debt in with the deliverable.

Fixed fee or time and materials when the need is discovered along the way

Time and materials fits situations where the content of the work cannot be settled in advance:

  • a product whose scope becomes clearer through use, delivered in increments;
  • an exploration or framing phase, whose result nobody can promise;
  • reinforcing an existing team, or bringing in a missing skill for a limited period;
  • ongoing changes, whose order shifts with business requests.

It has one condition, which weighs on the client: a person empowered to set the priorities, and tracking that compares, in each period, the time consumed with what has been delivered. Without this leadership, time risks passing without anyone being able to say what it has produced.

A programme may bring together several contracts, some on a fixed fee, others on time and materials. The milestones of a fixed-fee work package then depend, in places, on work carried out on time and materials by another team. Tracking these dependencies between contracts falls to programme management, whose conduct is described on our programme management page.

Between the two, mixed forms with shifting vocabulary

Three intermediate forms are found, under names that vary from one contract to another.

The fixed fee by work package chains short commitments: the content of each package is settled once the previous one has been delivered. Work units rest on a catalogue of standard tasks, each with a price; the client orders units, and the provider commits to each one. Capped time and materials, sometimes called “régie forfaitée” in French contracts, bills time spent within the limit of an agreed volume or amount.

The same project may also change model from one phase to the next: time and materials for framing, a fixed fee for a stabilised work package, time and materials again for changes. Whatever the name, three clauses state the real model: what the provider commits to, who bears an overrun, how a change is handled.

French law behind the two models

French contract law distinguishes the obligation of means, by which a party undertakes to apply appropriate diligence, from the obligation of result, by which it undertakes to achieve a specified result. Practice links time and materials to the former and the fixed fee to the latter. The wording of each clause, however, sets the nature of the obligation, whatever the title of the contract.

French labour law also regulates the supply of staff between companies, through the notions of unlawful lending of labour (article L. 8241-1 of the French Labour Code) and the offence of “marchandage” (article L. 8231-1). A time and materials arrangement in which the client behaves as the employer of the provider’s staff (individual instructions, working hours, leave, appraisal) is exposed to this risk. Qualifying a given situation is a matter for your lawyers.

Before launching the tender

The choice is prepared in writing, by answering the following questions:

  • can the expected result be described and accepted now, or only after a first phase?
  • who, on your side, will set the priorities and track progress each week?
  • who pays if the effort exceeds the estimate, and up to what amount do you accept it?
  • how will a change request be estimated, decided and recorded?
  • do the acceptance criteria cover tests, documentation and code quality, beyond features?
  • have your lawyers reviewed the nature of the obligations and the conditions under which the provider’s staff work?

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Another question? Ask us

What is the difference between fixed fee and time and materials?

Under a fixed fee, the provider commits to delivering a result described in advance, for an overall price and by an agreed date; it organises its own work and bears, unless otherwise agreed, any overrun in effort on a constant scope. Under time and materials, it makes available skills billed for the time spent; the client sets the priorities and bears the effort actually consumed. The first model assumes a need that can be described, the second a client that leads the project itself.

Do time and materials and technical assistance mean the same thing?

The two terms are used interchangeably to refer to making skills available, billed for the time spent. A contract may be titled "technical assistance" where the teams speak of time and materials. The title is not enough to know the model: the content of the clauses says what the provider commits to.

What is "flat-rate time and materials" (régie forfaitée)?

The expression has no single definition. Depending on the contract, it refers to time and materials whose volume of days and budget are set in advance, or to a service billed for time spent with delivery objectives attached. In both cases, have what is promised specified in writing: a number of days, a spending cap or a result.

Can an agile project be run under a fixed fee?

An agile approach lets the scope evolve as the product is used, whereas a fixed fee sets it. The two can be reconciled when the fixed fee covers a short unit, such as a work package or an increment whose content is finalised just before it starts, or when the contract provides for exchanging one feature for another of equivalent effort. A single fixed fee covering a whole product whose content is still to be discovered leads to a succession of change requests.

Who pays for an overrun in a fixed-fee project?

On a constant scope and unless otherwise agreed, the overrun in effort remains with the provider: it is the risk it accepted when setting its price. Requests outside the scope are estimated and give rise to a contract amendment, paid for by the client. Delays attributable to the client, such as a late answer or an unavailable environment, may be invoked by the provider according to what the contract provides; hence the value of recording every dependency and every decision.

A project to bring to completion?

A first conversation is enough to understand your challenge, identify the right people and tell you frankly what we can bring.