Definition of the Cloud Act
The Cloud Act is a United States federal law. Its full title, Clarifying Lawful Overseas Use of Data Act, gives the acronym. The text forms Division V of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2018 (Public Law 115-141), enacted on 23 March 2018.
It amends Title 18 of the United States Code, including Chapter 121, which the law describes as commonly known as the Stored Communications Act. This chapter governs the disclosure to authorities of data held by two categories of providers: electronic communication services and remote storage and processing services (remote computing service).
What Congress set out to resolve
Section 102 sets out the findings of Congress. Access to data held by providers is presented there as an essential component of the fight against serious crime. According to Congress, it ran up against the impossibility of obtaining data stored outside the United States by a provider subject to US jurisdiction. Providers, for their part, may find themselves caught between the conflicting obligations of two States.
The two parts of the law
The first part rests on Section 2713, which Section 103 of the law adds to Title 18. A provider must comply with its obligations to preserve, back up or disclose the contents of communications and information relating to a customer or subscriber, as long as it has them in its possession, custody or control, whether or not these are located in the United States.
The same Section 103 opens a remedy. The provider may ask the court to modify or quash the request if it considers that the customer is not a “United States person”, does not reside in the United States and that disclosure would risk violating the law of a “qualifying” State, linked to the United States in particular by an executive agreement in force.
The second part, in Section 105, concerns these agreements. They allow providers to respond to requests from the authorities of a partner State. The United States Department of Justice publishes the agreements signed with the United Kingdom (3 October 2019) and Australia (15 December 2021), and reports negotiations with Canada and the European Union.
Cloud Act, GDPR, Data Act, SecNumCloud: not to be confused
The Cloud Act is a text of US law, to be distinguished from three European or French references.
- The GDPR, Regulation (EU) 2016/679. Its Article 48 deals with judgments of courts or decisions of authorities of third countries requiring the transfer or disclosure of personal data: they may only be recognised or enforceable if based on an international agreement in force, “without prejudice to other grounds for transfer pursuant to this Chapter”. How a US request fits with Union law is a matter for lawyers.
- The Data Act, Regulation (EU) 2023/2854, whose Article 32 covers access by third-country authorities to non-personal data held in the Union.
- SecNumCloud, the ANSSI qualification framework for cloud service providers, some of whose criteria concern the provider’s exposure to non-European legislation.
A concrete case: an email service hosted in France
Take a French manufacturer whose email service is hosted in France by the European subsidiary of a US group. The address of the data centre does not settle the question: Section 2713 reasons in terms of possession, custody or control.
It remains to be determined whether the entity holding this data is subject to US jurisdiction. According to the United States Department of Justice, this jurisdiction is not limited to US companies without being unlimited, and the control exercised over data held by a subsidiary is assessed case by case. The answer belongs to the manufacturer’s lawyers.
The company can set the level of requirement for each class of data (location, law applicable to the provider, custody of encryption keys), following the approach on our sovereign and hybrid cloud page.